Is Online Dating (match.com/eharmony/etc) Pathetic For Someone In My Situation?

So here’s my story. I’m 19 going on 20 and currently finishing my junior year in college. I’m quite sick of dead end college relationships.
For starters most people that go to my school live too far away from my hometown for anything serious to ever happen.
Secondly, all the girls are dead ends. Either you meet them somewhere and take them on a date which goes well (and yes…I know what a bad date is like) and then you follow up and they never return your call. Or relationships that just plain don’t last because it’s blatantly obvious they just want to screw around with other guys and they cover it up with the lame excuse “it’s not you, it’s me”.
I know for a fact it’s not an attraction issue. Not to toot my own horn, but many girls have told me I was hot/cute/etc and some have even approached me at parties and such. I just get so annoying when I see couple on campus and can’t figure out how the hell they can be so lucky.